Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karen's avatar

I have a different perspective: agreeableness is all about self-interest. It looks like other-interest, but that's what defenses do - they portray positive qualities to distract from the qualities we've rejected. It looks like compassion or kindness, but its really a way of managing low self-esteem.

If I agree with you,

- you'll accept me. If I told you what I really wanted, you'd hate me. Everybody would.

- I'm protected from your opinions. If I agree, you won't argue, criticize my choices, or "make me feel bad."

- I'm protected from my own vulnerability. Agreement keeps me safe from divulging how I feel and who I really am.

Since you're happy that I agree with you, I fool myself into thinking you like me. So I forget my original misconception & start seeing myself as someone who is likable because I'm giving and agreeable. That's who I am. And I continue the behavior without thinking.

NT's self-interest is the lessening of psychological conflict. Being agreeable appears to accomplish that for some people.

But defenses aren't really effective; the original issue - low self-esteem - is still there. So agreeableness isn't really in our self-interest. But the psyche thinks that it's better than dealing with esteem. So the psyche, who runs the show, thinks it's in our self-interest.

Not everyone is ready to explore it. So the psyche might be correct in its evaluation. Sometimes, defenses are the best one can do.

Invisigoth's avatar

Funny thing about this. I regularly get calls to come fill in teaching martial arts classes. I don’t get paid for it but I will almost always do it because I have fun. When I don’t such as a recent request I flat said no I have something else going on and that was accepted with no questions.

I realize that if you do what you want without being wheedled you won’t likely be pestered when you say no.

30 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?