Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Karen's avatar

I have a different perspective: agreeableness is all about self-interest. It looks like other-interest, but that's what defenses do - they portray positive qualities to distract from the qualities we've rejected. It looks like compassion or kindness, but its really a way of managing low self-esteem.

If I agree with you,

- you'll accept me. If I told you what I really wanted, you'd hate me. Everybody would.

- I'm protected from your opinions. If I agree, you won't argue, criticize my choices, or "make me feel bad."

- I'm protected from my own vulnerability. Agreement keeps me safe from divulging how I feel and who I really am.

Since you're happy that I agree with you, I fool myself into thinking you like me. So I forget my original misconception & start seeing myself as someone who is likable because I'm giving and agreeable. That's who I am. And I continue the behavior without thinking.

NT's self-interest is the lessening of psychological conflict. Being agreeable appears to accomplish that for some people.

But defenses aren't really effective; the original issue - low self-esteem - is still there. So agreeableness isn't really in our self-interest. But the psyche thinks that it's better than dealing with esteem. So the psyche, who runs the show, thinks it's in our self-interest.

Not everyone is ready to explore it. So the psyche might be correct in its evaluation. Sometimes, defenses are the best one can do.

Expand full comment
Invisigoth's avatar

Funny thing about this. I regularly get calls to come fill in teaching martial arts classes. I don’t get paid for it but I will almost always do it because I have fun. When I don’t such as a recent request I flat said no I have something else going on and that was accepted with no questions.

I realize that if you do what you want without being wheedled you won’t likely be pestered when you say no.

Expand full comment
31 more comments...

No posts